Shoulder Elbow iSAWE 5

Question

A 25 year old cyclist falls onto the point of his shoulder. There is a step at the acromioclavicular joint, and radiographs show the clavicle displaced superiorly by twice the width of the shaft.

Shoulder Elbow iSAWE 5, ap radiograph of the shoulder
AP radiograph of the shoulder. Image by Root4(one), Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.5.
  1. How are these injuries classified?
  2. What would you look for on examination and imaging?
  3. How would you manage this patient?

Answer

Classification (Rockwood)

TypeFeatures
IAC ligament sprain, no displacement
IIAC ligament torn, CC ligaments sprained, under 25% displacement
IIIAC and CC ligaments torn, 25 to 100% displacement
IVClavicle displaced posteriorly through trapezius
V100 to 300% superior displacement with deltotrapezial fascia stripped
VIClavicle displaced below the coracoid

Examination and imaging

  • Reducibility of the clavicle with shoulder shrug, which suggests intact deltotrapezial fascia
  • Posterior displacement is best seen on an axillary view
  • Zanca view (10 to 15 degrees cephalic tilt) and bilateral weighted comparison views
  • Neurovascular examination and associated coracoid or clavicle fractures

Management

  • Types I and II, sling and early motion
  • Type III, most do well without surgery, with fixation considered for heavy manual workers, overhead athletes or persisting symptoms
  • This injury is type V, so surgical reconstruction is usually recommended
  • Acute repair with a suture button or hook plate, or reconstruction of the CC ligaments with tendon graft for chronic injuries
  • Types IV and VI need open reduction and stabilisation

Related pages

Author Contributions

Orthofracs team

Reviewed by Professor Phong Tran, Head of Orthopaedic Surgery, Western Health. Last updated 10 October 2026.